Sunday, 18 January 2009

And what did you do . . .

in the war, Mr Hamas?

“I showed the world how ruthless, destructive tand vengeful the Israelis could be, destoying homes, schools, hospitals, mosques, and over 6, 000 of ‘my people’s’ lives.

And how many Israeli tanks did you disable or destroy?

“- - -”

And how many Israeli mortar or machine gun platoons did you successfully attack?”

“- - -”

And how many Israeli soldiers did you kill?

“13?”

“Are you sure those deaths were not 'friendly fire' accidents?”

“- - -”

Did you not have an advantage in urban warfare?

“We chose not to endanger our loyal and innocent civilian population.”

Ah.

Do you think you have performed militarily as well as Hezbollah during the Israeli invasion of Southern Lebanon?

"- - -"

What exactly have you achieved?

“The people of Palestine know now for certain that Israel is their enemy forever, that they will never be able to be assured of living in peace and will always be threatened by them.”

Were they not aware of this before?
So what else have you achieved?

“The embargo that will be instituted by Israel, Egypt and the West will further reduce the situation of the Palestinian population.”

Yes. And so?

“They will become yet more angry and militant and rise up in their masses to support Hamas and attack the Israeli occupiers.”

As they have in this last few weeks?

“- - -”

You will be calling elections to confirm this support?

“- - -”

Well, and now, Mrs Hamas, how did you and your children enjoy the war?

Some of my best friends . . .

might not be Israeli any more. This is one of the very few eyewitness reports (out of thousands) of an attack on a civilian's home to appear on the mainstream media in the US. The victim is a Gazan doctor who works in Israel.



The background story appears to be this:

"So, Israel's channel 10 is interviewing its regular "good Palestinian", Dr. Az A-Din Abu al-Ayash, an OB-GYN who actually works at Israel's Tel HaShomer hospital outside Tel Aviv [. . .]

So Channel 10's Shlomi Eldar is interviewing the good doctor by phone, live on TV, when suddenly there's a boom and the doctor begins to scream "Oh god, they killed my daughters".

. . . One of our tanks missed its actual target and took out the good Dr's house, killing two of his daughters and injuring a third (who [. . .] was airlifted to the same hospital where her dad works).

This, by the way, happened after the doctor complained earlier in the week that a tank with its barrel pointed directly at the his window was making him nervous. So Ronni Daniel, [the . . .embedded IDF reporter] military reporter for Channel 2, reportedly spoke to the commander in question and got him to point that thing someplace else. Only temporarily, as it turns out."


(from 'Ricky B' (New Yorker, living in Israel) in 'Open Salon'. http://open.salon.com/content.php?cid=84825)

Square brackets indicate where I have removed defamatory phrases in the original.

Saturday, 17 January 2009

Then and Now in Gaza

This boy now. . .












. . .might have been this boy then.


(Photographer of boy with candle in Gaza unknown; on the right, by Mohammed Abed, for AFP.)

The Catalogue of Crime



So, at last, after so many attacks, so many incursions, so many 'targeted assassinations' patience with Israel has snapped. A state that is sixty years old can no longer assume impunity. UNWRA has warned that it is 'keeping a catalogue' of all Israeli actions which could be considered War Crimes.

This time, it is doubtful that even the most complacent American administration can save them. And Obama and Clinton must by now be all too aware that anything more than words of sympathy will merely increase the loathing of (in many countries) or distaste for (in most others) the USA.

They must know, among their European allies in NATO, several of whom have firmly resisted the previous administration's attempts to turn NATO into a kind of 102nd Division bound for Afghanistan, that any hope of military co-operation must be close to zero.

So Israel's foreign minister made a dash to Washington to get a last ditch promise to effectively starve and economically ruin the Gaza Strip for ever, by effectively asking the USA to assist with tightening and maintaining its blockade.

In other words, to continue the job that the war was intended to accomplish, but for which, now, there is simply not enough time.

The agreement is a 'memorandum of understanding', and therefore, hopefully not binding, for if the Obama administration conforms to its intent, the results will simply defeat any aspirations he may have to restore his country's reputation and influence anywhere else in the world.

But in the meantime, of course, the agreement has no doubt covered the last shipment of hundreds of tons of munitions the US has on the high seas for use in the last few days before Obama gets a grip. And the confirmation hearings have not yet ended, so in effect, his administration will be powerless well into January.

Whatever hopes there may be for a ceasefire, a complete one on the Israeli side, could well therefore be delayed for another two weeks or longer. It cannot necessarily be assumed that it might be an Israeli Inauguration present.

Especially when you read the story of munitions shipments on their way from the US to Israel:

"We know that the Wehr Elbe, a German-owned cargo ship left the USA on 20 December 2008 with a large consignment – 989 containers - of high explosives and other munitions destined for Israel," said Malcolm Smart, Director of the Middle East and North Africa Programme.

"Hired and now legally controlled by the US Military Sealift Command, it was heading for the Israeli port of Ashdod and was due to transit via Greece, though its latest reported position indicates that the shipment's route may have changed."


Tenders for two other arms shipments totalling 325 containers of US munitions were approved by the Pentagon on 31 December, four days after the start of Israel's current attacks on targets in Gaza.


These two consignments were due to be shipped to Ashdod from Askatos in Greece, but they have now been cancelled, according to information provided to Amnesty International by the US Military Sealift Command.


Tender documents show that these shipments contain white phosphorus, known for its potential to cause severe burns and an indiscriminate weapon when used as an airburst in densely-populated civilian areas as now alleged in Gaza.


The US Department of Defence says it is now looking at other means to deliver the munitions to a US stockpile in Israel. A US-Israel agreement has allowed US munitions stockpiled in Israel to be transferred to the Israeli Defence Force in "an emergency".


[from 1158munich.blogspot.com/ sources not confirmed.] Did the foreign minister's dash to Washington really have anything whatsoever to do with discussing a ceasefire? It would be rather naive after this to believe it.