Saturday, 10 January 2009

Propping up the Cause against the Palestinians




You have already heard this from many interviewees on the broadcast media who purport to be independent and even objective, as well as from official Israeli spokespersons.


[“Hamas’] senior leaders completely abandoned the population and are concerned only in saving their own skiins.”

“. . . mosques, institutions and private homes were being used by Hamas as bases of operation and arms caches. The entire terror infrastructure is located in the heart of the civilian population which acts as a human shield.”

“Hamas has placed almost a million Israeli civilians within its range of fire (about 15% of its total population!) No country in the world would agree to daily fire at its civilians’ homes.

“Stopping [Operation Cast Lead] midway will not only lead to a resumption of terrorism but will also serve as encouragement to Hamas and other extremist elements in the region.”

“There is today no humanitarian crisis in the Gaza Strip . . .(in the course of the past week 400 trucks and 10 ambulances entered the Gaza Strip from Israel.)”

“The figures we have indicate that the percentage of casualties among univolved civilians stands at about 12% (50 out of 400 killed), much lower than any similar event such as NATO’s bombing in Kosovo or Afghanistan.”


A communique sent by the Israeli foreign Ministry to “media volunteers” who are asked to flood blogs, websites and media with these points if they respond to this email:

“Dear friends,
We hold the [sic] military supremacy, yet fail the battle over the international media. We need to buy time for the IDF to succeed, and the least we can do is spare some (additional) minutes on the net. The ministry of foreign affairs is putting great efforts in balancing the media, but we all know it's a battle of numbers. The more we post, blog, talkback, vote – the more likely we gain positive sentiment.”

As you can see from reading many media blog threads which do not even originate any discussion of the Gaza War, they are often sidetracked into it, presumably frequently by volunteers who have taken up the invitation.

My Arab friends have often, and still do, bewail the Palestinians’ apparent inabilty to produce rational and reasoned counter-argument, let alone similar counter-propaganda . . .But then, may not in the end, the views and opinions of those who honestly believe in their cause, the reports of eyewitnesses, outweigh the manufactured propaganda and partial representations?

We can hope so; propagandists seldom seem to remember that the most effective propaganda is truth and the evidence of truth.

See The Guardian

Friday, 9 January 2009

Truth will out even in Gaza. . .



. . .even when the controlling forces ban journalists and cameramen in the hope that pictures and stories will not illustrate their actions to the rest of the world.

The BBC broadcast two interviews with eyewitnesses, children (one 13) who are being treated for their injuries after being rescued from the house Israeli soldiers tricked over a hundred people into believing would be a place of safety, and then, in total breach of the Geneva Conventions, shelled it.

They tell their stories simply, with obvious honesty and directness, and they are compelling and distressing to anyone who believes they have the right to call themselves humane and civilised.

What makes it a war crime is not just that deceit, not just deliberately and consciously targeting civilians, men, women and children, but that for four days they refused to allow medical help to reach them.

An interview with an Israeli spokesman (fortunately recorded by the BBC before the interviews with the two surviving children, or no doubt the story would have changed) produced what for years so many of us have come to expect even when we do not know the real story: half-truths, lies, and propaganda.

Israeli troops were not operating in the area; Israel tries hard to avoid civilian casualties; this was an area where the population is under the thumb of Hamas and therefore could be persuaded to say anything; it is Hamas propaganda. In any case the Israeli army is investigating.

And that last phrase usually seems to mean 'investigating as to how this crime can be covered up, made to appear the fault of the victims, or, as an absolute last resort, which Israeli soldier is most expendable and can be charged later with mere 'neglect of duty' or something minor.

I do not for a moment think that many American citizens, or Israeli ones, though there will be some who dare to speak out, will not swallow the initial Israeli story. There are enough friends of Israel to swamp a great deal of the American media with it, and for many, it will no doubt believed more true with time.

But the rest of the world, I think, is becoming thoroughly sickened by this kind of thing. Though I have avoided writing it, comparisons between the behaviour of the SS in Jewish ghettoes in World War II and some Israeli behaviour in Gaza now are inescapable.

And I trust it will be a source of shame for generations of Israelis to come that they allowed to happen, have called for, and have supported, some of the very abuses that they have for sixty years held another nation, now much changed, to account for. And to which they claim they owe in part the legitimacy of their state.

I think you will find the interviews here on BBC World Service Newshour for the rest of the day.


Determination and Desperation in Gaza and Israel

So, the Israelis are determined to continue their ‘reduction’ (military planners prefer that to ‘destruction’ or ‘annihilation’) of the Gaza Strip despite the UN Resolution. Hamas, with absolutely nothing to lose, not even life, since now so much of that has been lost anyway, are determined to continue whatever resistance or attacks they can put together.

The determination of Hamas, of course, is born of desperation, of fear that at some stage they will be exhausted both of men and arms, and wiped out in Gaza and possibly anywhere else in future. And the desperation of the whole populace, who have been driven to shiver and starve as the Israelis have finally almost entirely have deprived them of homes, power, fuel and food.

Eighty per cent of Gazans now require food aid; only ten per cent will get it, since although some food can get to warehouses, as the Israelis humanely open a crossing for an aid convoy, it cannot be distributed to the majority of the citizens as the Israelis have destroyed the infrastructure through which it could be delivered. It is of course, the old Israeli tactical trick of giving with one hand while taking away with the other and previously having taken a great deal with both.

So, as Gazans are still proving stubborn, are still not marching in the streets to plead with the Israelis to finally take them over as a client, pliant, colony; are not marching in the streets demanding that Hamas (now, in Israel-speak “this murderous Palestinian organisation”: you see the Israeli desire now to extend their ‘reduction’ to the Palestinians of the West Bank?) goes into exile on a cruise liner, nor demanding they cease rocketing Israel. As if they could: who could dare, could be determined enough, to risk even standing for ten seconds in a street knowing that they would be targeted almost instantly and the house they stepped out of shelled or reduced to add to the rubble blocking the roads?

So, the determination of the Israelis to effectively destroy Palestine and reduce Palestinians to a state of utter despair and incapacity is unabated. Its public expression, yet again, adopts the pseudo-legitimacy of the language of Americans in their war on terror. They will not be ‘dictated to’ by ‘foreign countries’, least of all, now, by such as ‘American cheeseburger-eating surrender monkeys’.

This is where, as many of us anticipated, where American foreign policy and ‘pre-emptive’ military ‘armed diplomacy’ has led: to ruthless action by a ruthless state under the guise of protecting its statehood and its own self-respecting, self-obsessed status and power apart from the rest of the world. It is an attitude that has brought the USA in the end to an economic collapse and an international disrespect that not even the most liberal new President (and Obama is not that for all his outward charm) can cure for a generation.

In its desperation and defiance, Israel is set on a course to follow its mentor, but unlike its parent, it cannot threaten countries internationally. The USA has bought (no doubt with of offers of finance it could never, it turns out, afford anyway, or threats of withdrawal of arms and technology, a couple of European countries to place its ‘Star Wars’ stations in them. The whole of Europe is now reaping the rewards of this American intervention aimed at Russia. (It is ludicrous to suppose that antimissile missiles, never yet proven to work in the way they are claimed to, must be placed in Poland or the Czech Republic to intercept missiles fired from Iran or North Korea.) All those states bordering on Russia are now short of gas in a cold winter, and in terms of heating will be no better off than the Gazans who have equally been deprived. In desperation, are they going to turn to the USA for energy it neither can nor would supply to Europe? Rather they are going to abandon it.

What countries can Israel buy or threaten to support it against the Palestinians, apart from the USA? Just as despised, it can only rely on propaganda ; or will it dare, finally, in desperation at losing all international support as the UN Resolution now shows with even the USA abstaining instead of vetoing it as it has done so many times before, threaten, sub rosa, the use if its own terror weapon, its nuclear arsenal on its feared near neighbours?

The Russians have learnt that the USA is powerless and impotent in some areas in which it has (literal) power; that in the field of energy supplies its supposed power of ‘protecting its allies’ is meaningless. It, and no doubt others will find more holes in that fabric, and the USA, like Israel, will no doubt find itself in the desperate situation of being almost entirely without allies and friends.

Yesterday, while the US was still blocking any UN resolution that was not kind to Israel and cruel to the Palestinians, President-elect Obama held a press conference in which he refused to answer any questions on Gaza. However, a correspondent described his body language showed he was very angry. Perhaps it was the knowledge that within a matter of days American policy over Israel might change was what finally persuaded the American ambassador, a friend ot the notorious Neocons who led the USA into these disasters of intervention in the name of the ‘War on Terror”, the same the Israelis immediately adopted as excuse for any of their own actions, to abstain.

In any case, the determination of the Israelis, who immediately said the cease-fire resolution was ‘unworkable’ without, obviously, even discussing it, makes almost any new American policy also unworkable in the short term, unless Obama can raise the determination to defy the powerful Jewish-American lobby that has kept the USA in such close step with their spiritual homeland.

Meanwhile, the situation of all Palestinians will remain desperate. A hundred civilians. it is reported, were recently ‘encouraged’ by Israelis who controlled a part of southern Gaza to take shelter inside a house. Which the Israelis shelled. The ambulances finally allowed in by the Israelis could not reach the dead and wounded: they had to be carried to them on carts. There are eyewitness testimonies. Many will be determined that the Israelis should stand before an international tribunal for war crimes when this is finally over. Or as, if Israel cannot e stopped, the skeletons of the starving are collected from the ruins of Gaza.

Possibly, all the Israelis can hope for in future support from the USA may be that an Obama administration might bow to a Jewish lobby and prevent that final humiliation. And then, of course, any suggestion of morality in either ‘democratic’ state would be in shreds.

Wars that arise out of small events in their turn create other events and those lead to greater events that unpredictably dwarf those out of which the war began. That was true of the Hundred Years’ War, the Thirty Years War, the First World War, the War on Terror and will be true of this.

And, of course, in all this, no-one has been saying very much of self-determination.

Delivery expected here soon


. . . of, I hope, more food for thought, unlike in Gaza, where the UN says 80 per cent of the population of 1.5 million requires food for the body which because of Israeli military actions and destruction can only be delivered to ten per cent.